The Event:January
20 marked the culmination of an incredible two years
in American political history. From his declaration
as a candidate in February 2007 to his nomination and
election in 2008 to his inauguration on Tuesday,
Barack Obama has astonished the world. In a vicarious
way, we have accompanied him on this journey. We
started our trip with a fundraiser in our apartment
two years ago, a trip that culminated with the
swearing-in ceremony this week at the Capitol.
Starting as one of the most improbable candidates,
Barack Obama has become the nation’s first
African-American president.
Taking
the oath
We just spent four days in Washington. We experienced
high points and low points, and I mean some that were
really high and others that were really low. But the
unquestioned zenith occurred noon Tuesday when Obama
took the oath of office. To witness it in person was
a thrill that far overcame the inconveniences and
discomforts of the crowds, the lines, and the bitter
cold.
President Obama leads the parade
A
few others joined us to witnesses history The
Speech: Is
there anyone who has not yet weighed in on “the
speech”? Unquestionably, it had substance, including
a litany of the domestic and international challenges
that we face. But did it soar, did it meet the high
expectations that we all had for what many thought
might become “the speech of all time”? Clearly, not.
The bar had been set too high, particularly by Obama
himself. His earlier speeches, and particularly his
coming-out speech at the 2004 Democratic convention,
engendered the hope for a ringing address, one for
the ages. But as it turned out, there was no
particular part of the speech, not even a phrase,
that will live in history. Nothing he said will
equal, or even come close to, the emotional impact of
the opening line of his Iowa caucus victory speech:
“They said this day would never come.” That, my
friends, is a line for history.
Overall, it was a fine speech, an appropriate one,
and one that received mostly accolades from across
the political spectrum. Yet there were critics, even
among his supporters. Paul Krugman, one of his most
enthusiastic champions, weighed in with what could be
called at bestfaint praise:
“…there wasn’t anything glaringly wrong…”
Adlai
Stevenson:Most
analyses of Obama’s speeches have focused on
comparisons with presidential predecessors,
particularly Franklin Roosevelt and John Kennedy. But
the speaker with whom I think he is closest, both in
style and substance, is Adlai Stevenson. In 1952, I
was a 19-year-old, too young to vote under the then
law, but nonetheless a campaigner for Adlai Stevenson
in his losing battle against Dwight Eisenhower.
Re-reading some of Stevenson’s speeches today, they
still evoke thrills, even a half-century later. His
1952 Democratic nomineeacceptance
speech,
“…Let’s talk sense to the American people. Let’s
tell them the truth, that there are no gains
without pains, that we are now on the eve of great
decisions, not easy decisions…” evoked the
language and message of Obama’s inaugural address.
By the way, before he was a presidential candidate,
Stevenson served as Illinois governor (at a time
before they routinely served in prison). His wit and
quickness are illustrated in an appearance he made on
a television quiz program. He was asked to give a
ten-letter answer to the question, “What is a synonym
for security”? After a short pause, he responded,
“For a man, employment; for a woman, engagement.”
Yes, I know, politically incorrect, but this was
almost 60 years ago, and damn, it wasquitean
answer.
A
small quibblewith
Obama’s speech. The third paragraph in the speech
begins “Forty-four Americans have now taken the
presidential oath…” In actuality, Obama is the
forty-third American to have taken the oath. Because
Grover Cleveland servednonconsecutive
terms, he is usually double counted when compiling
the number of presidents in our history.
Depression-era song, Obama-era suggestion:As a fan
of film and theater, I was amused by the following
advice he offered (without attribution) in his speech
to those suffering in this economic crisis:
“Starting today,
we must pick ourselves up,
dust ourselves off,
and begin again the work of remaking America.”
Some of us old-timers recognize that these words were
appropriated from the songPick Yourself
Up,
written by Dorothy Fields (lyrics) and Jerome Kern
(music), and sung by Fred Astaire and Ginger
Rogers and the 1936 film,Swing
Time. The
lyrics of the song offered a lift for those
suffering in the depths of the Depression. An
excerpt:
“Nothing’s impossible I have found,
For when my chin is on the ground,
I pick myself up,
Dust myself off,
Start all over again
Watching
the inauguration – Plan B:We never
made it to theCapitol
grounds.
Because of a sticky situation (see Purple Gate
hell below), we were unable to get to our reserved
viewing area, even though we had tickets. So we
went to our fallback position, an office building
located conveniently close to the ceremony. From a
high window perch and from the roof – move over,
Secret Service – we were able to witness the
proceedings. What’s more, we enjoyed the
additional conveniences of food, drink, and
bathrooms. In life, Plan B sometimes triumphs over
Plan A.
Terrific
dinner party:A
highlight of our Washington stay. On the night before
the inauguration, we attended one of the ten charity
dinners in private homes that featured a celebrity
chef. I don’t know about the other dinners, but ours
had all the elements of a top Washington soirée. The
guest list came from central casting, and included a
newly minted cabinet secretary, a top member of the
new economic team, several best-selling authors and
Pulitzer Prize winners, a sprinkling of business
execs, an assortment of NGO type, a few
not-for-profit doyennes, and at least one unemployed
blogger. The tony Georgetown venue was, of course,
perfect.
Our host gave us the rules of the evening: “All
conversation is off the record. All, that is, unless
it’s really juicy.”
And then there was the dinner itself. Well, the food
that was served by our celebrity chef turned out to
be an acquired taste, and I haven’t yet acquired the
taste. Included among the five courses were pig
snout, lamb’s neck, and an egg cooked for one hour
forty-five minutes at very low temperature (115°).
The chef explained the rationale for this unusually
long and low-temperature method. But after eating the
egg, I could not for the life of me figure out why
this protracted technique beats boiling one for three
minutes. But then what do I know aboutSlow Food?
West
Side Story:Another
high point of the trip. We caught the penultimate
Washington performance of a new production
that’sheaded for Broadwayin a
month. This classic 1957 musical offers the great
Bernstein-Sondheim music and lyrics, the
remarkably faithful re-creation of the original
Jerome Robbins choreography, and Arthur Laurents’
book and direction. But a new twist was added to
this production that was designed to enhance the
verisimilitude. The Sharks (the Puerto Rican gang)
sing and converse in Spanish. Even for those of us
who for some reason took French in high school, it
works.
The
(ugh) Inauguration Balls:Inaugurations
are famous for the black-tie balls. They’re
plentiful, they’re big, and they’re forgettable, not
necessarily in that order. We had tickets to the
Eastern Ball, one of the seven “official”
geographical balls; there were a host of others. Ours
was located in Union Station and was one of the
smaller balls -- only 3,000 attendees. The
Mid-Atlantic ball at the dreaded Convention Center
had 8,700 attendees. Trés intime, n’est-ce pas?
Because of security, cars could not drop off guests
at the front door of Union Station. So we took a
several-block walk in the frigid weather. Arriving
frozen, we entered the massive space, assaulted by
the amplified music that was deafening in what was,
in effect, a giant echo chamber. After all, a train
station is not exactly a concert hall.
We headed for the nearest bar. The bartender: “You
need drink tickets.” Me: “Youmustbe
kidding.” He wasn’t kidding. After contributing and
raising alotof
dollars for the campaign, after giving money to the
transition committee, after buying VIP tickets for
the ball, and after getting dressed up in black tie
and arriving frozen, we were greeted (if that is the
term) with a cash bar. Very classy.
Aha! We discovered we were not in the VIP area.
Surely that would be different. Reaching the VIP
area, such as it was, same greeting: no ticket, no
drink. The buffet table, however, was ticket-free. It
was also taste-free. We bolted.
So here’s the bottom line on inaugural balls. There
isnoreason –
none – for ever going to one. Noisy, crowded,
impersonal, lousy food, endless coat-check lines,
lots of standing around waiting for the First Couple
to arrive. Sound good? Don’t be tempted.
Howard
Dean Reception:Another
low point. On Saturday evening, fresh from the
glorious West Side Story performance, we attended a
reception at the National Museum of American History
honoring the outgoing DNC chairman, Howard Dean. If
you can conceive of a downscale version of an
inaugural ball, this was it. I assume that Howard
Dean eventually made it there. We were long gone.
But before leaving, we did get to see fragments of
the originalStar-Spangled
Banner, the
flag that inspired the National Anthem. It
inspired us, and is well worth seeing.
Purple
Gate hell:A low
point of our trip. Donna and I had received purple
tickets to witness the inauguration ceremony.
Now understand, these were not tickets for seats;
these were just entrée into the standing area on the
Capitol grounds designated on theinaugural mapas
purple, immediately behind the seated guests.
Nonetheless, we were happy to get them, and looked
forward to watching the ceremony from ground
level. It was not to be.
As has been reported since in newspapers and a lot of
angry blogs, tens of thousands of ticketed attendees
were unable to get through the Purple Gate (or the
Blue Gate on the other side of the viewing area,
which had the same problem). It was a massive
management failure. Too many tickets were issued,
gates opened too late, too few screening
magnetometers were in place, there were too few
police or security people, and fewer still who had a
clue as to where we should go.
Many of the people waiting to enter had been in line
outside or in a nearby tunnel for hours in
sub-freezing cold with zero information. And the
lines didn’t move. They were getting angrier and
angrier as inauguration time approached.
It was not a pretty sight, as documented by the
photos below from a Facebook group, “Survivors of the
Purple Tunnel of Doom.” Note in particular the
comments of frustration and anger below the photos.
Hundreds of photos were posted.
By the way, the D.C. chief of police stated after the
inauguration that everyone who wanted to get into the
viewing area was able to do so.
Not true.
The purple gate happened to be within yards of the
entrance to our Plan B office building. We gave up on
trying to get through the gate. We just wanted to go
the thirty yards to the building. We started with
polite “excuse me” requests. These soon escalated to
strong imprecations, not suitable for a family blog.
Thirty minutes to go thirty yards. Anyway, we finally
got to the building and didn’t venture out until long
after the crowds dispersed.
The
poem:
Elizabeth Alexander delivered an original
poem,Praise
Song for the Day, at the
inauguration ceremony. Hearing it, and later reading
it, the poem reminded me of why so few of us pay much
attention to contemporary poetry. I felt very little
emotional impact or intellectual stimulation. It was
a modest message with little rhythm and, of course,
no rhyme. (I believe you get drummed out of the poets
union if your poems rhyme.) To me, it sounded and
read and looked more like a modest few paragraphs of
prose (with a lot to be modest about).
In grammar school, we read (okay, we were forced to
read) and recited poetry; I even remember some of
those poems to this day. My guess is that little
poetry is read or recited in schools today. I also
suspect that Ms. Alexander’s inauguration poem will
do little to reverse that trend.
To get a flavor for it, here are the last seven lines
of Elizabeth Alexander’sPraise Song for the
Day:
“…Love beyond marital, filial, national,
love that casts a widening pool of light,
love with no need to preempt grievance.
In today’s sharp sparkle, this winter air,
any thing can be made, any sentence begun.
On the brink, on the brim, on the cusp,
praise song for walking forward in that light.”
Let’s compare this with a poem written for an earlier
president. I dug up the 77-line poem,Dedication, that
Robert Frost wrote for John Kennedy’s 1961
inauguration. (Frost, when he got to the podium,
was unable to read it because the sun reflected
too brightly on his paper; instead, he delivered a
different poem from memory. Try that one, Mr.
Chief Justice.) The last eight lines ofDedicationare:
“ …It makes the prophet in us all presage
The glory of a next Augustan age
Of a power leading from its strength and pride,
Of young ambition eager to be tried,
Firm in our free beliefs without dismay,
In any game the nations want to play.
A golden age of poetry and power
Of which this noonday’s the beginning hour.”
Perhaps a new golden age’s beginning hour began
noonday January 20.
Lilly
Ledbetter:During
the course of our four days, we couldn’t help but run
into alot of
bold-face names. They were everywhere. To their
credit, they all respected my privacy; none asked for
an autograph.
Lilly
Ledbetter
But one
who impressed us greatly was not a famous actor, or
TV personality, or politician. She was a former
Goodyear factory worker,Lilly
Ledbetter, who
is now on the cusp of bold-facedness (is this a
word?). At a luncheon we attended on Sunday,
orgnized by our friend Sunny Goldberg and her
Mamas for Obama group, we met this Ms. Ledbetter.
She had led an unsuccessful equal-pay fight for
many years that finally ended up in the Supreme
Court. The adverse ruling was based not on the
merits, but rather on the court’s denying her
right to sue on what was, in effect, a
technicality. That will change. In the next few
days, one of the first acts that President Obama
will sign into law is theLilly Ledbetter Fair Pay
Act.
The
bottom line?Was our
excellent adventure in Washington worth the inflated
hotel prices, the frozen toes, the numb fingers, the
endless lines, the intrusive security, the ridiculous
balls. The answer is, absolutely yes. We relate to
the ubiquitous person-in-the-street interviews we saw
and conducted during our stay. When asked, why are
you here, every answer was the same: “This is
history.” Indeed it was. For them, for us, and for
the nation. We were there.
Our
favorite wrap-up:The
following advertisement from Hammerstein Light and
Power (no kidding) appeared in a half-page display ad
in the Jan. 21 New York Times. Its message, drawn
from the musical theater, is succinct and perfect.
Would
we ever do it again?Absolutely
not. There will be more inaugurations, but there will
never be another moment like this in our lifetime. So
here’s our plan: On January 20, 2013, we’ll be
sitting in front of our widescreen TV with drink in
hand in our warm apartment and we’ll toast the
president – from 200 miles away. As to doing it
again, we share the sentiment of the woman who gives
this view of love in Stephen Sondheim’s cabaret
song,I Never Do Anything
Twice.
“…Once, yes, once for a lark
Twice, though, loses the spark
One must never deny it
But after you try it you vary the diet…
Once, yes, once can be nice
Love requires some spice
If you’ve something in the view
Or something to do, totally new
I’ll be there in a trice
But I never do anything twice…”
The
day before
Lines
everywhere
Celebrating
on the Reflecting Pool ice after the
ceremony
Taken
on Jan. 19. The lines were longer on Jan.
20.